Perceptual-cognitive three-dimensional multiple-object tracking task can help the monitoring of sport-related concussion

NeuroTracker baselines are significantly more accurate at detecting mTBI status 48-hours post-injury and RTP readiness than traditional assessments.

Image
Medical
Athletes

August 2018

in

BMJ Open Sport & Exercise Journal

Icon
Icon
Icon
Icon
Icon
Icon

Aim

To investigate if the major need for more effective concussion assessment tools in sports can by be addressed by NeuroTracker, and to compare any differences with traditionally used assessments.

Icon

Method

59 professional athletes were tested with NeuroTracker (3 Core sessions), the Standardized Assessment of Concussion (SAC), and the Modified Balance Error Scoring System (M-BESS) tests, each at 48 hours following a concussion injury. The tests were repeated at return-to-play (RTP) status following a standard concussion management protocol. The majority of athletes were classed with severe concussions, as determined by an expert neurologist. Additionally, normative NeuroTracker data for healthy elite athletes was used for analytical reference, along with pre-season baselines on SAC and M-BESS tests for 32 out of the 59 of the injured athletes.

Icon

Result

Multiple statistical analyses of the tests revealed the following. Compared to health athletes, the learning function within the 48 hours of concussion was totally disrupted for the injured athletes. NeuroTracker scores at 48 hours were significantly lower than normal, and correlated to the total number of symptoms reported. NeuroTracker scores for the RTP evaluations revealed a significant improvement in NeuroTracker scores (though still below healthy athlete levels). In comparison the SAC and M-BESS tests’ usefulness for monitoring concussion was found to be weak, with limited or negligible correlation to pre-season baselines, as corroborated in other studies. For the first time, this study demonstrates the unique role of NeuroTracker to monitor sport-related concussion, addressing some of the requirements needed to appropriately respond to real-world sport-specific demands.

Similar Research

Medical
Feb 2022

A combined 2-week NeuroTracker and Dynavision training intervention improves cognitive motor functions impaired in child cancer survivors.

The feasibility and efficacy of short-term visual-motor training in pediatric posterior fossa tumor survivors
European Journal of Physical and Rehabilitation Medicine

To evaluate the efficacy of short-term cognitive and motor training aimed on visual-motor integration in PFT survivors using training devices.

63 children cancer survivors between the ages of 6 and 17 years were tested for baseline levels on cognitive and motor functions. The patients were then split into a no-intervention group and an intervention group who undertook 6 sessions of cognitive motor training (NeuroTracker and Dynavision) over 2 weeks. Both groups were then baselined again.

Primary results revealed that the cognitive motor training intervention increased gross and fine motor skills, motor coordination, visual-motor integration, and visual processing. Secondary results showed that age was a sensitive factor in the cancer-related decline in cognitive, motor and eye functions, as well as the specific characteristics of the cancer. The researchers concluded that such short-term rehabilitation methods can be useful in pediatric oncological practice.

Medical
Apr 2016

A single session of NeuroTracker is a useful indicator of the effects of mTBIs.

Effects of Mild Traumatic Brain Injury on 3D Multiple Object Tracking Performance
Athletic Training & Sports Health Care

To determine if NeuroTracker (3D-MOT) can serve as an effective concussion assessment tool.

485 participants (8 to 71 years) with and without a history of concussion completed a 3-session NeuroTracker baseline.

Significant main effects were found on NeuroTracker scores for participants with a history of mBTI, most notable in the first of the 3-sessions. The results suggest that even a single session of NeuroTracker (6-mins) is a useful indicator of mTBI.

Medical
Dec 2019

NeuroTracker is a safe and promising tool in the clinical management of pediatric mTBIs.

Perceptual-cognitive training after pediatric mild traumatic brain injury: Towards a sensitive marker of recovery
Escholarship McGill

To address current research gaps in the clinical management of pediatric mTBI and to see if use of NeuroTracker can help overcome such gaps.

As a first stage 213 children were rigorously assessed within 10 days of sustaining an mTBI injury to determine if such assessments could be predictive of recovery time. A second stage assessed the feasibility of 10 mTBI symptomatic children tolerating 6 NeuroTracker sessions. The third stage of the study compared differences in NeuroTracker learning rates between 20 post-mTBI children and 14 healthy children. The fourth stage compared 10 children clinically recovered from mTBI with 10 healthy children. The final stage compared NeuroTracker learning rates between 10 clinically recovered mTBI children and 12 children at various stages of recovery.

The first stage found that a combined post­‐concussion symptom score was effective at predicting delayed recovery. The second stage found NeuroTracker training training was well tolerated and considered to be safe in symptomatic pediatric mTBI. The third stage found both groups improved on NeuroTracker with training, but that initial learning rates were lower for the mTBI group. The fourth stage found no differences in NeuroTracker learning between clinically recovered mTBI children and healthy children. The final phase found children in various stages of recovery had lower initial NeuroTracker learning rates compared to the clinically recovered group. The researcher concluded NeuroTracker to be a safe and promising tool in the management of pediatric mTBIs.

Medical
May 2019

mTBI individuals initially show lower performance than healthy controls on NeuroTracker, but show strong learning responses specific to 3D training.

A comparison of two-dimensional and three-dimensional perceptual cognitive training in concussed populations
University of Victoria Libraries

To investigate the performance of NeuroTracker multiple object tracking (MOT) training in 2D and 3D environments, in both healthy and concussed individuals, across three study environments.

86 participants between the age of 8 and 91 years of age, completed 30 NeuroTracker sessions over the course of ten visits. The individuals were assigned to one of three studies: an environment comparison of 2-D vs 3-D training (n=58), a comparison of 3-D training among aging populations (n=38), or a comparison of 3-D training among concussed populations (n=34; non-concussed, recently concussed and prolonged concussed).

NeuroTracker training in 3-D showed benefit across age groups and concussed populations, demonstrating that all individuals could increase performance. When comparing learning performance between aged individuals, NeuroTracker learning rates increased at a lesser rate (p<0.05). Trends were similar for the concussed group, where the longer an individual was suffering from concussion symptoms, the lower the initial NeuroTracker score. However, they also showed a higher rate of learning performance throughout training. Of particular interest was the response to the 2-D and 3-D training environments. Significant differences were apparent when the environments were compared, with participants in the 3-D environment outperforming the individuals in the 2-D environment. Additionally, switching from the 3-D to the 2-D environment was shown to be detrimental to performance.

The author concluded that it appears the brain does not process monocular cues (2-D) for a 3-D environment, at the same rate or skill level, as it can binocular cues for a 3-D environment (3-D). As the participants training in 3-D showed a higher learning curve throughout the training program, these findings further demonstrate the added benefit and learning potential when training MOT in a 3-D environment.

Medical
Rehabilitation
Jun 2017

SCAT3 and KDT correlate significantly with the variance in NeuroTracker baselines across large male and female athlete populations.

Relationship between King Devick TEST, SCAR3 and 3D mot in cognitive assessment
British Journal of Sports Medicine

To examine baseline relationships between the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool 3 (SCAT3), the King-Devick Test (KDT) and 3D Multiple Object Tracking (NeuroTracker).

304 healthy, non-concussed, athletes (101 females, 203 males), ranging in age from 11-20 years old, completed the SCAT3, KDT and NeuroTracker in a single visit. The results were analysed to see if any aspects of the SCAT3 or the KDT predicted 3D NeuroTracker baselines.

Component tests of the SCAT3 and KDT explained a significant amount of the variance in NeuroTracker speed thresholds. King Devick Test, Delayed Recall, and coordination tests had the highest predictive validity for NeuroTracker baselines. The authors suggest that these correlations could lead to valuable information to better inform clinicians responsible for making Return to Play determinations.

Rehabilitation
Medical
May 2018

Youth with clinically diagnosed mTBI can benefit from NeuroTracker training with significant learning effects.

Three-dimensional multiple object tracking in the pediatric population: the NeuroTracker and its promising role in the management of mild traumatic brain injury
NeuroReport

To examine NeuroTracker learning effects in youth with and without mTBI, and investigate if NeuroTracker can train visual perception after mTBI for stimulating recovery and informing return to activity decisions.

34 male and female participants, aged 9–18 years, completed 18 NeuroTracker Core sessions spread out over 6 visits. 20 of the participants were controls, with no history of mTBI. 14 participants had a recent history of mTBI, but were symptom free.

Both groups improved on the NeuroTracker task over time. The control group showed a strong learning curve, with a 79% increase in speed thresholds over the course of the training. The mTBI group showed minimal learning over the first 6 sessions, then a similarly strong learning curve over the following 12 sessions, with a 66% increase in overall speed thresholds. The difference in learning over the first 6 sessions suggests that cognitive deficits persist at a symptom free stage of post-mTBI, and that better clinical assessments are needed to reveal such functional deficits. The results showed that both healthy youth and youth with mTBI can benefit from NeuroTracker training with significant learning effects. This study suggests that NeuroTracker could serve as an inexpensive and easily accessible tracker of recovery for pediatric mTBIs, and that children may benefit from the training following mTBI.